Science & technology | Predicting pugnacity

How to forecast armies’ will to fight

What motivates the dogs of war?

IN JUNE 2014 around 1,500 partisans of Islamic State (IS) attacked Mosul, a city in northern Iraq. They were outnumbered almost 15 to one by government troops defending the place. The result was a rout. But not in the direction those numbers might have suggested. In the face of the enemy, the government soldiers ran away. Reflecting shortly thereafter on America’s failure to foresee what would happen, James Clapper, then Director of National Intelligence (and thus America’s top spy) described a force’s will to fight, or lack thereof, as an unpredictable “imponderable”.

This article appeared in the Science & technology section of the print edition under the headline “What motivates the dogs of war?”

America’s ugly election: How bad could it get?

From the September 5th 2020 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

Illustration of the Zlatý kůň/Ranis group.

Humans and Neanderthals met often, but only one event matters

The mystery of exactly how people left Africa deepens

llustration showing two human profiles facing each other, connected by beams of light and shapes, representing the translation process

Machine translation is almost a solved problem

But interpreting meanings, rather than just words and sentences, will be a daunting task


Illustration of a face, focusing on the mouth with beams of light and shapes, representing the speech creation

AI can bring back a person’s own voice

And it can generate sentences trained on their own writing


Carbon emissions from tourism are rising disproportionately fast

The industry is failing to make itself greener

Why China is building a Starlink system of its own

When it is finished, Qianfan could number 14,000 satellites, rivalling Elon Musk’s system

Lots of hunting. Not much gathering. The diet of early Americans

What they ate is given away by the isotopes in their bodies