United States | A victory for democracy

The Supreme Court declines to upend American election law

A fringe theory gets a chilly reception from the justices

Three police officers stand guard outside the U.S. Supreme Court.
Image: Reuters
|New York

IN THE RUN-UP to the 2020 presidential election—and in its fraught denouement—supporters of Donald Trump turned to a novel theory to boost their candidate’s chances of staying in the White House. Citing the “independent state legislature” theory, they sought to block state-court rulings in Pennsylvania and elsewhere that made voting easier during the covid-19 pandemic by, for instance, extending deadlines for mail-in ballots. And after election day, legal advisers drew on the notion in cooking up a radical scheme to replace electors in states won by Joe Biden with “alternative” slates for Mr Trump.

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline “A victory for democracy”

From the July 1st 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from United States

The White House has been fluid on gender for a decade

Trump’s order “restoring biological truth” will not be the last word

President Donald Trump talks to reporters after signing executive orders in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington.

A controversial idea to hand even more power to the president

Impoundment is about to come a step closer



Tom Homan, unleashed

America’s new border czar spent decades waiting for a president like Donald Trump

An unfinished election may shape a swing state’s future

A Supreme Court race ended very close. Then the lawyers arrived.

Donald Trump cries “invasion” to justify an immigration crackdown

His executive orders range from benign to belligerent