United States | Legally bland

At American law schools, a fresh fuss over freedom of speech

A botched event at Stanford rekindles controversy

2M5RW1E Close-up of law school text on brown wall at Stanford University
Image: Alamy
|New York

“DO YOU sodomise your wife?” When a law student posed this query to Antonin Scalia during a Q&A at New York University in 2005, the audience was shocked. But the event resumed and the impertinent question to the Supreme Court justice was not quite a non sequitur: two years earlier the arch-conservative had written a strident dissent defending the constitutionality of laws banning sodomy.

This article appeared in the United States section of the print edition under the headline “Legally bland”

From the April 8th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from United States

Police officers and mental health nurses gather around a man with mental health issues at a subway station in New York City.

New York City commits to involuntary commitment 

Compulsory treatment of the severely mentally ill was once taboo. No longer

Trump on a playing card

Donald Trump is turning payback into policy

And setting new, dangerous precedents for the American presidency


President of Ultimate Fighting Championship Dana White, Eric Trump, Susie Wiles and Lara Trump listen as President Donald Trump speaks.

Florida comes to Washington, DC

Using the Sunshine State’s politics as a guide to the Trump administration


The clean-up after the LA fires is already revealing tensions

When a city burns, how does recovery even begin?

RFK junior and Tulsi Gabbard, set to sail through a cowed Senate

But Congress will bargain harder on taxes and spending

Elon Musk is shredding America’s government as he did Twitter

Some of his operatives are barely out of their teens