The Americas | Sub-national and sub-optimal

Latin America’s local governments too often fail their people

A forthcoming paper shows the effects of bad government

A resident of Nueva Union shantytown buys water from a tanker truck in Villa Maria del Triunfo, a poor district in Lima, Peru’s capital.
Troubled watersImage: Reuters
|Buenos Aires

As Latin America underwent its stunning shift from dictatorship to democracy in the 1980s and 1990s, new constitutions were written. Mindful of past experiences with strong central governments, many countries devolved powers to local ones. The share of expenditure controlled by sub-national layers of government almost doubled between 1985 and 2015, to 25%. The World Bank and other institutions applauded. Local governments, they reckoned, would respond better to their constituents.

This article appeared in the The Americas section of the print edition under the headline “Sub-national and sub-optimal”

From the August 19th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from The Americas

Canada Prime Minister Justin Trudeau makes an announcement outside Rideau Cottage in Ottawa.

Justin Trudeau leaves a wrecked party and divided Canada

Mark Carney and Chrystia Freeland are among those tipped as the next Liberal leader

A collage illustration showing a cutout of XI Jinping's facing Donald Trump's face on the right with a small cutout image of Claudia Sheinbaum between them. Behind them are some shipping containers and the The San Lázaro Legislative Palace of Mexico along

Does made in Mexico mean made by China?

Donald Trump believes Mexico is a trojan horse for Chinese mercantilism


People stand on the destroyed Saopin bridge due to the flooding of the Cangrajal river.

Failure to prepare for climate change is costing Honduras dear

Weeks after the most recent storm, the country is still in emergency mode


Venezuela’s Nicolás Maduro looks set to take the throne

Relying on a fabricated election victory, the incumbent will be sworn in again

Why Spanish firms have cooled towards Latin America

Slow growth and messy politics are largely to blame

Latin Americans are worryingly relaxed about authoritarianism

The Latinobarómetro poll shows a region that is happier with its democracies, but at ease with illiberalism