International | Wagner in Israel

To play or not to play

An emotive debate about music raises new questions about Israel’s identity

|jerusalem

SHOULD an informal ban be lifted on public performances in Israel of the work of Richard Wagner, an anti-Semitic German composer admired by Adolf Hitler? Democracy, freedom of choice, Holocaust survivors' sensitivities—all are part of the mix of an emotive debate that has troubled Israel for decades but is now back in a fresh guise. The Berlin Staatskapelle, under its maestro Daniel Barenboim, an Argentine-born Jew who grew up Israel, is due to perform one of Wagner's most controversial pieces, the first act of “Die Walküre”, as the centrepiece of a state-sponsored festival in Jerusalem to be held on July 7th.

This article appeared in the International section of the print edition under the headline “To play or not to play”

The rights and wrongs of killing Tim McVeigh

From the May 12th 2001 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from International

An illustration showing a man and woman holding a baby together and smiling. Through a window behind them a woman can be seen in a hospital bed and a doctor is closing the blinds.

As adoptions collapse, demand for international surrogacy is soaring

Yet it is facing a growing backlash from religious conservatives and some feminists

An illustration of Donald Trump and Xi Jinping sititing at a table carving up a globe on a plate with knives and forks. Steam is rising from the globe.

A big, beautiful Trump deal with China?

Washington hawks puzzle over calls for China to help in Ukraine, and hints of a possible TikTok reprieve


An illustration of a plug and a socket separated but a fence with barbed wire.

Why don’t more countries import their electricity? 

The economics make sense, but the geopolitics are nerve-racking


Trump unmasks American selfishness, say cynics

But sceptics are wrong to call America First business as usual

Inside the Houthis’ moneymaking machine

After a ceasefire in Gaza, they may continue their Red Sea racket

Marco Rubio will find China is hard to beat in Latin America

China buys lithium, copper and bull semen, and doesn’t export its ideology