Finance & economics | Free exchange

How NIMBYs increase carbon emissions

Opposition to new buildings has unfortunate consequences

Illustration of a man looking over a fence through a cloud of smoke
Illustration: Álvaro Bernis

A shopkeeper’s son smashes a window, causing a crowd to gather. Its members tell the shopkeeper not to be angry: in fact, the broken window is a reason to celebrate, since it will create work for the glazier. In the story, the crowd envisions the work involved in repairing the window, but not that involved in everything else on which the shopkeeper could have spent his money—unseen possibilities that would have brought him greater happiness. The parable, written by Frédéric Bastiat, a 19th-century economist, sought to draw attention to a common form of argument, which has come to be known as the broken-window fallacy.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline “Anti-environmentalists”

From the March 16th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Finance & economics

A white fish going into the ,outh of a group of black fishes forming a bigger fish.

Why your portfolio is less diversified than you might think

The most important idea in modern finance has become maddeningly hard to implement

A German flag waves in front of the buildings of the banking district in Frankfurt, Germany.

Can Germany’s economy stage an unexpected recovery?

The situation is dire, but there are glimmers of hope


Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni smiles at the Palazzo Chigi in Rome.

Giorgia Meloni has grand banking ambitions

Will Italy’s nationalist prime minister manage to concentrate financial power?


Tech tycoons have got the economics of AI wrong

Following DeepSeek’s breakthrough, the Jevons paradox provides less comfort than they imagine

Donald Trump’s economic warfare has a new front

The president has threatened to blow up the global tax system. Will allies be able to stop him?

Don’t let Donald Trump see our Big Mac index

America’s tariff-loving president could learn the wrong lessons from international burger prices