Britain | Bagehot

Are British voters as clueless as Labour’s intelligentsia thinks? 

How the idea of false consciousness conquered the governing party

Someone with their eyes blindfolded
Illustration: Nate Kitch

Woe it is to be a Labour wonk right now. A streak of nihilism has infected the party’s boffins after Kamala Harris’s defeat in the American presidential election. The American economy zoomed under Joe Biden yet voters defenestrated his party. Essays such as “The Death of Deliverism” by Deepak Bhargava, Shahrzad Shams and Harry Hanbury, which argued in 2023 that voters would not thank Mr Biden’s Democrats for a thumping economy, are passed around the British left like sombre samizdat texts.

Explore more

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “The triumph of false consciousness”

From the November 30th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Britain

Crew members during the commissioning of HMS Prince of Wales

Has the Royal Navy become too timid?

A new paper examines how its culture has changed

A pedestrian walks across the town square in Stevenage

A plan to reorganise local government in England runs into opposition

Turkeys vote against Christmas


David Lammy, Britain’s foreign secretary

David Lammy’s plan to shake up Britain’s Foreign Office

Diplomats will be tasked with growing the economy and cutting migration


Britain’s government has spooked markets and riled businesses

Tax rises were inevitable. Such a shaky start was not

Labour’s credibility trap

Who can believe Rachel Reeves?