Britain | Crime and pointless punishment

Why short prison sentences in England and Wales are a disaster

They reveal deep flaws in the criminal-justice system

Image: Nate Kitch

THE THREE weeks Liam spent in prison after he rashly opened a can of beer in a shop and swigged from it cost him and the taxpayer vastly more than the £1.90 ($2.40) he had failed to pay. He stole while he was beset by mental-health problems and a failing relationship. Prison made his troubled life worse. Released, he found he had been kicked out of his flat, so had to move away from the relatives and friends on whom he relied. He lacked cash because universal credit, a benefit for those on low incomes, stops during prison sentences (new applications take a month to begin). All this made him feel desperate. Again, he stole a small amount of alcohol. This time, because he was on probation, he got seven weeks. In less than a year he went to prison four times.

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “Crime and pointless punishment”

From the July 1st 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Britain

A57 Snake Pass in the Peak District, Derbyshire.

Why Britain has fallen behind on road safety

More than 1,600 people still die each year in road collisions

Stock price information displayed on a board at the London Stock Exchange.

Britain’s brokers are diversifying and becoming less British

London’s depleted stockmarket is forcing them to change


Sculpture by Charles Jencks of DNA double helix Cambridge University.

What a buzzy startup reveals about Britain’s biotech sector

Lots of clever scientists, not enough business nous


Britain’s government lacks a clear Europe policy

It should be more ambitious over getting closer to the EU

The Rachel Reeves theory of growth

The chancellor says it’s her number-one priority. We ask her what that means for Britain