Britain | Bagehot

British voters want more immigrants but less immigration

The government’s immigration policy is incoherent because voters are incoherent 

The biggest lie in British politics is that voters want honest debate. Whenever a policy problem emerges, sensible types call for the trade-offs to be laid out before an informed voting public who will carefully weigh the options. Anyone who has sat through a focus group or gone canvassing with a politician knows this is nonsense. When faced with an either/or question, British voters usually give a decisive answer: “yes”.

This article appeared in the Britain section of the print edition under the headline “More immigrants, less immigration”

From the May 27th 2023 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Britain

U.S. President-elect Donald Trump and Elon Musk.

Blighty newsletter: What Westminster gets wrong about Elon Musk

Illustration of Keir Starmer choosing between two shirts - one with red stripes and one with red dots. He looks confused.

The four worst words in British politics 

Saying “not a good look” is not a good look


Protesters holding placards demand urgent action on the city's rising rents.

Inflation in Britain looks irritatingly persistent

Worse, the risk has appeared just as growth is sputtering


Labour lacks good ideas for improving Britain’s schools

Making private ones a bit more expensive is not an inspiring start

Britons brace themselves for more floods

A warming planet is making a soggy island soggier 

Why meal-replacement drinks are shaking up the British lunch

They are being rebranded as aspirational as well as efficient